[Solved]: Trouble understanding how to pick constants to prove big theta

Problem Detail: So I’m reading Introductions to Algorithms and sometimes I wish it would be a little bit more friendly with how it explains topics. One of these topics is proving big-theta. I understand that the definition of $Theta$ is as follows:

$Theta(g(n)) = f(n)$ if there exists positive constants $c_1$, $c_2$, and $n_0$ such that $0 le c_1 g(n) le f(n) le c_2 g(n)$ for all $n ge n_0$.

In other words, for $f(n)$ and $g(n)$, $f(n)$ can be bounded by $c_2 g(n)$ from above and bounded below by $c_1 g(n)$. So the example in the book goes:

Show that $frac{1}{2} n^2 – 3 n = Theta(n^2)$.

From the definition of big theta: $$ c_1 n^2 le frac{1}{2} n^2 – 3 n le c_2 n^2$$ CLRS begins by dividing by the largest order term of $n$ which is $n^2$ to get $$ c_1 le frac{1}{2} – frac{3}{n} le c_2 $$ From here we split the problem into two parts, the right-hand inequality and the left-hand inequality. On the right hand side: CLRS chooses $c_2 ge frac{1}{2}$ because for $n gt 1$, $frac{1}{2} – frac{3}{n}$ can never be less than $frac{1}{2}$ since $frac{3}{n}$ goes to $0$ as $n$ goes to infinity. (I’m assuming they choose $n gt 1$ here because if $n=0$ then we would be dividing by $0$.) Now this is where I start to get lost. On the left hand side: CLRS chooses $c_1 = frac{1}{14}$ (not sure why) and $n ge 7$. I’m not sure what the significance of these choices is. At $n le 6$, $frac{1}{2}-frac{3}{n}$ becomes negative. But why $frac{1}{14}$ for $c_2$? I’m just not sure how they arrived at solving the left hand side and the book doesn’t really explain it well for me.

Asked By : Harrison Nguyen

Answered By : p.j

For $n leq 6$, $$ 1/2 – 3/n le0, $$ so if you are taking integer value of $n$, put $n = 7$ as it gives $1/14$. This is how he arrived in the conclusion i.e., for $n geq 7$, $$ 1/2 – 3/n ge1/14, $$ because $n$ is in the denominator it will only decrease the value of -ve term, so overall value will increase with $n$, which is the constant $c_1$.
Best Answer from StackOverflow

Question Source : http://cs.stackexchange.com/questions/14326